By Michael Skerker
The act of interrogation, and debate over its use, pervade our tradition, no matter if via fictionalized depictions in videos and tv or discussions of real-life interrogations at the information. yet regardless of day-by-day mentions of the perform within the media, there's a loss of knowledgeable remark on its ethical implications. relocating past the slender concentrate on torture that has characterised so much paintings at the topic, An Ethics of Interrogation is the 1st ebook to totally deal with this advanced factor. In doing so Michael Skerker confronts a number of philosophical and criminal concerns, from the fitting to privateness and the privilege opposed to forced self-incrimination to prisoner rights and the felony effects of other modes of arrest, interrogation, and detention. those subject matters increase critical questions on the morality of maintaining secrets and techniques and the diversities among kingdom energy at domestic and in a foreign country. considerate attention of those topics leads Skerker to express coverage suggestions for legislations enforcement, army, and intelligence professionals.
Read or Download An Ethics of Interrogation PDF
Similar criminal law books
This booklet contributes to the talk at the influence of eu group legislations at the nationwide constitutional orders and cultures of the respective Member States. the writer examines the doctrine of sovereignty as a mechanism during which this impression could be top assessed and particularly the way it underwrites the strain among eu Union rights and the rights supplied via the respective felony orders of the Member States.
Offering an advent to, and specified exam of major, enforcement and procedural points of foreign felony legislations, this book’s exam of foreign and transnational crimes below treaty and common legislations has been totally up to date and revised. Exploring the enforcement of foreign legal legislation via an research of the perform of the protection Council-based tribunals for Yugoslavia and Rwanda, the foreign felony courtroom and different hybrid tribunals, similar to these for Cambodia, Sierra Leone, Lockerbie and fact commissions, the authors examine terrorism, offences opposed to the individual, piracy and jurisdiction, and immunities among numerous different themes.
Is the forget of monetary, social and cultural abuses in foreign legal legislation an issue of optimistic overseas legislations or the results of offerings made through legal professionals taken with mechanisms corresponding to legal prosecutions or fact commissions? Evelyne Schmid explores this question through an overview of the connection among violations of financial, social and cultural rights and overseas crimes.
Alex Alexandrowicz spent 22 years in custody protesting his innocence. This e-book explains how whatever which begun with him pleading to blame (wrongly) within the trust that he could serve a 'short' sentence changed into a Kafkaesque nightmare. Alex's tale is put in viewpoint through BBC television 'Crime Squad' presenter Professor David Wilson.
Extra resources for An Ethics of Interrogation
By “dissent,” I mean the rejection of some state of affairs through critique. I do not mean disobedience, withdrawal of fealty, or other, more general relational state of affairs. ” This is an assertion made in a context that makes the speaker’s stated or implied goals contrary to the actual end states his proposed actions will likely bring about. ” Kant’s moral and ethical restrictions turn on practical self-contradictions. For example, Kant’s objection to the consumption of mind-altering substances is based on the self-contradictory nature of freely choosing to consume substances that inhibit one’s ability to make choices.
Jones’s action may be motivated by self-interest as well. In violating Livingston’s rights, Young wrongs more than Livingston; he indirectly wrongs all other persons in the sense that Young arrogates to himself more freedom than is consistent with universal exercise. He has abused a right and wronged all others in taking a liberty he cannot extend to them; he is benefiting more than they from the (supposedly) common self-limiting of each person’s Autonomy, Rights, and Coercion / 23 freedom. He was able to get the jump on Livingston because Livingston was not readying a similar plan of assault and theft targeting him.
We begin with the assumption that all persons are autonomous, with moral rights as expressions of that autonomy, as discussed in the preceding chapter. We saw there that rights presuppose the legitimacy of coercive measures to protect those rights. Being able to fully exercise one’s rights during the full, natural course of one’s life implies two different kinds of freedom. As the terms are commonly used by philosophers, negative freedom means the absence of external impediments to one’s actions, and positive freedom means the ability to plan and lead one’s own life within the scope of one’s rights.